As a Reincarnated Aristocrat, I’ll Use My Appraisal Skill to Rise in the World (Rating 3.75)

Amazon Link

Summary

Score

Overall Review

• The story excels across a wide range of elements, including originality, thematic depth, and the charm of its characters.
• Notably, the unique ideas and fresh settings shine, with the characters’ growth and individuality deepening the story, effectively drawing in readers and viewers.
• Additionally, the pacing of the narrative and emotional beats is finely tuned, maintaining an engaging rhythm that keeps the audience hooked until the very end.
• The visual expressions and the impact of the title also enhance the work as a whole, with memorable elements that linger.
• However, there are moments where certain elements feel similar to existing “isekai” works, which may be a bit familiar.
• Overall, this is a highly polished and captivating work. Definitely worth checking out!

Synopsis

• A young man who dies in an unexpected accident is reincarnated as the third son of a noble family in a new world.
• Using his unique skill, “Appraisal,” he decides to rise through the ranks in his new life, recognizing the talents of himself and those around him.
• The story follows his growth as he overcomes the strict class system of noble society and the schemes of others, alongside his companions.
• Amidst a tale of rising to power and unlocking potential, what future does the protagonist aim for?

Detailed Evaluation

Story (Score 11.6/18.5)

1. Originality and Freshness of Ideas (3.6/6.0)
   The story, based around the “Appraisal Skill” within the popular “isekai” genre, feels somewhat fresh.
   However, the setting follows many familiar tropes, leading to some sense of déjà vu.
2. Themes and Messages (3.0/5.0)
   The theme of rising through effort and ingenuity is appealing, but it feels a bit shallow at times, with some missed depth, perhaps due to prioritizing readability.
3. Risk-Taking Attitude (1.0/2.5)
   As an “isekai” work, it doesn’t take many risks.
   The narrative follows a more stable, predictable path rather than being particularly daring.
4. Expectations for Ending (4.0/5.0)
   The story progresses steadily, with sufficient foreshadowing based on the appraisal skill.
   There’s an increasing sense of anticipation for the ending.

Character (Score 13.1/18.5)

5. Uniqueness and Impressions (4.0/5.0)
   The protagonist stands out due to his unique appraisal skill, with clever uses of it throughout.
   However, the supporting characters might feel somewhat generic at times.
6. Growth and Internal Consistency (4.0/5.0)
   The protagonist’s growth in ability is reflected in his psychological development.
   His actions make sense, especially with the rise in his social status.
7. Character Conviction and Relatability (3.6/6.0)
   While the protagonist’s background is explored, there are fewer emotionally charged scenes to fully connect with him. The relatability feels average.
8. Relationships with Other Characters (1.5/2.5)
   Relationships with supporting characters serve the plot but lack significant dramatic depth.

Visuals (Score 18.3/23.5)

9. Character Design Originality (4.0/5.0)
   The fantasy-inspired character designs blend well with the world, but there are moments where they feel similar to other existing designs.
10. Character Movement and Expression (4.0/5.0)
    Expressions and movements are natural, complementing the story.
    Though not groundbreaking, the execution is solid.
11. Background and Worldbuilding (4.0/5.0)
    The worldbuilding is detailed and immersive, with backgrounds seamlessly integrated into the narrative.
    However, there are a few panels with minimal background that might leave a slight impression of incompleteness.
12. Sense of Immersion (4.8/6.0)
    Action and strategy scenes are well-paced, drawing the reader in.
    Yet, there are moments, especially in the daily scenes, where immersion feels somewhat weak due to drawn-out foreshadowing.
13. Innovation in Expression Techniques (1.5/2.5)
    While there’s little innovation in techniques or structure, the use of established methods is skillfully done.

Pacing (Score 17.8/21.0)

14. Pacing of the Introduction (5.0/5.0)
    The setting and developments are smoothly introduced, sparking immediate interest in the story.
15. Smoothness of Development (4.0/5.0)
    The story flows without unnecessary detours.
    Some rapid developments, such as the protagonist’s rise in status, feel abrupt at times.
16. Presence of Lulls (4.0/5.0)
    There are moments in the middle where the story slows down, especially as the protagonist becomes proficient in his skills and gains new companions, but overall, it remains engaging.
17. Build-Up to the Climax (4.8/6.0)
    The story steadily builds to the climax.
    There are no major surprises, but it maintains a solid, reliable structure.

First Impressions (Score 4.0/5.0)

18. Cover/Key Visual Impact (2.0/2.5)
    The cover design is eye-catching, though it feels somewhat familiar for the “isekai” genre.
19. Title Impression (2.0/2.5)
    The title is catchy and communicates the genre well, but it’s hard to avoid the feeling that it shares similarities with other “isekai” titles.

Volume Count

17 volumes (ongoing as of this review)

Author

Author

• Original Story: A Future Man
• Manga by: Natsumi Inoue
• Character Design: jimmy

Other works

• –

Amazon Link